To be honest, this was the least mind blowing set of MAC lipsticks for a while. Surprisingly, we ended up impressed with "Petit Red" mainly because we couldn't find anything like it in our collection. It's lighter than most reds and way more muted. A perfect strawberry shade for Summer. Both "Petit Red" and "Boca" are satin finishes while "Acai" is a matte. All are limited edition and sold out online. We will be doing the comparison of "Acai," "Rebel," and several other lipsticks soon (check out the dupes here)! Did you snag any of these?